Ben Emson
What is the Difference Between a Proc and a Lambda in Ruby?
The concepts of a Proc and a lambda in Ruby are subtly different and this post aims to try and explain the differences.
Procs and Lambdas
Firstly why do we need Procs and lambdas? In order to answer this you need to understand what a block is in Ruby.
Understanding what a block is?
A block is simply a piece of code, which is usually attached to a method, Proc or lambda. It is important to note that this block of code is NOT an object (yet...), it is code that is defined either within braces {} or within a do end container.
The code in a block is just logic that hasn't been wrapped into an object yet. When this block is passed to a method and that method has a yield statement then Ruby will wrap that block into a special type of object. That type of object is a Proc object. Once the block becomes a Proc Ruby can use it and the block code 'comes alive'.
Therefore we need a Proc object in order to handle blocks. The next question is how does a lambda fit in.
A lambda is a type of Proc object, it is almost completely identical to a Proc apart from two differences. This little code snippet shows that a Proc and a lambda are derived from the same superclass, Proc.
def what_are_lambdas_and_procs
puts "--- #{__method__} ---"
lam = lambda { puts 'lam variable assigned a lambda' }
lam.call
puts "lam is a class of: #{lam.class.name}"
puts "lam method count: #{lam.methods.size}"
puts
prc = Proc.new { puts 'prc variable assigned a Proc' }
prc.call
puts "prc is a class of: #{prc.class.name}"
puts "prc method count: #{prc.methods.size}"
""
end
This will output:
--- what_are_lambdas_and_procs ---
lam variable assigned a lambda
lam is a class of: Proc
lam method count: 55
prc variable assigned a Proc
prc is a class of: Proc
prc method count: 55
So what are the subtle differences between Proc and lambda?
As mentioned there are two differences, and these differences are :
- in how a Proc/lambda assigns arguments, and
- in what happens, when a Proc/lambda calls return within a caller method.
Proc, lambda argument assignment
When a lambda is called with more or less than the required number of arguments Ruby will throw an ArgumentError.
However when a Proc is called with more arguments, no error is thrown and the extra values are simply thrown away. When it is called with less arguments these parameters are simply assigned a value of nil.
These two code snippets demonstrate this:
def lambda_args
puts "--- #{__method__} ---"
lam = lambda { |a, b| puts "lambda with 2 arguments a:#{a}, b:#{b}" }
lam.call( "first", "second")
puts "lambda called with three arguments..."
begin
lam.call("first", "second", "third")
rescue
puts " ArgumentError: wrong number of arguments (3 for 2)"
end
puts "lambda called with no arguments..."
begin
lam.call()
rescue
puts " ArgumentError: wrong number of arguments (0 for 2)"
end
end
def proc_args
puts "--- #{__method__} ---"
prc = Proc.new { |a, b| puts "Proc with 2 arguments a:#{(a.nil?) ? "nil" : a }, b:#{(b.nil?) ? "nil" : b }" }
prc.call( "first", "second")
puts "Proc called with three arguments..."
prc.call("first", "second", "third")
puts "Proc called with no arguments..."
prc.call()
end
This will output:
--- lambda_args ---
lambda with 2 arguments a:first, b:second
lambda called with three arguments...
ArgumentError: wrong number of arguments (3 for 2)
lambda called with no arguments...
ArgumentError: wrong number of arguments (0 for 2)
--- proc_args ---
Proc with 2 arguments a:first, b:second
Proc called with three arguments...
Proc with 2 arguments a:first, b:second
Proc called with no arguments...
Proc with 2 arguments a:nil, b:nil
Proc and lambda return behaviour
When a lambda returns a value and this lambda is called within a method then method will simply continue it's execution until it itself returns a value.
However when a Proc returns a value and this Proc is called within a method this containing method will be exited WITHOUT any further execution. This is slightly surprising behaviour, and consequently a Proc should be handled with care.
These two code snippets demonstrate this behaviour:
def lam_return
puts "--- #{__method__} ---"
puts "simple function that calls a lambda and then returns it's own string."
my_lam = lambda { return 'Lambda has returned' }
my_lam.call
return 'lam_return method string returned'
end
def proc_return
puts "--- #{__method__} ---"
puts "simple function that calls a Proc, "
puts "UT instead of returning it's own string returns the Proc's string."
my_proc = Proc.new { return 'Proc string returned' }
my_proc.call # this function returns and finishes here
return 'proc_return method string returned' # the return is never called
end
This will output the following:
--- lam_return ---
simple function that calls a lambda and then returns it's own string.
lam_return method string returned
--- proc_return ---
simple function that calls a Proc,
BUT instead of returning it's own string returns the Proc's string.
Proc string returned
Proc return work around
There is however a very simple work around to avoid a Proc from returning out of it's caller method. Simply removed the return statement, because Ruby always returns the last line this last line will be returned automatically.
def proc_return_work_around
puts "--- #{__method__} ---"
puts "simple function that calls a Proc, \nhowever the method string still returns."
my_proc = Proc.new { 'Proc string returned' }
my_proc.call # this function returns and finishes here
return "#{__method__} method string returned" # the return is never called
end
This will output:
--- proc_return_work_around ---
simple function that calls a Proc,
however the method string still returns.
proc_return_work_around method string returned
Conclusion
As you have seen there are only two small differences between a Proc and a lambda but these differences have quite surprising behaviours. Therefore following the Ruby principle of "...least surprise", it is best practice to use lambdas over Procs unless you absolutely need the Proc behaviour.
For more information please see this article: http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Ruby_Programming/Syntax/Method_Calls
